If you're serious about dominating MLB The Show 25, your infield needs to be built around players who can do it all - mash home runs, field like gold glovers, and turn singles into doubles with elite baserunning. With the game's September tuning updates and MLB The Show 25 Stubs meta shifts, certain cards have risen to the top as true difference-makers. Whether you're grinding Ranked Seasons or building the ultimate Diamond Dynasty roster, these are the S-tier infielders - the ones who win championships.
First Base (1B): Power, Plate Discipline, and Presence
First base is traditionally the spot for sluggers, but in MLB The Show 25, versatility and approach matter just as much as brute strength. The top three names at the position not only bring insane power but also plate vision and consistency under pressure.
Bryce Harper (Philadelphia Phillies, 95 OVR)
Harper's 95 OVR first base card is an absolute menace at the plate. He mashes lefties and righties alike, and his power-to-contact ratio makes him a middle-order staple. What sets him apart is his Clutch and Bomber quirks, which make late-inning heroics feel inevitable. He's one of the few cards that can carry your offense even against elite pitching.
Freddie Freeman (Los Angeles Dodgers, 90 OVR)
Freeman is a contact king. His smooth left-handed swing, combined with impeccable vision, means he rarely strikes out. While not the flashiest, he thrives in high-pressure situations - perfect for players who rely on timing and plate discipline. His ability to spray hits across all fields makes him a nightmare for shift defenses.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Toronto Blue Jays, 90 OVR)
If you love moonshots, Guerrero Jr. is your guy. His raw power rating makes him one of the game's top-tier sluggers, and his Clutch Performer quirk means he gets even better in the late innings. Pair him with high-contact hitters, and you've got a balanced offense that keeps pitchers guessing.
⚡ Second Base (2B): The Versatility Kings
The middle infield is where defense meets speed - but in MLB The Show 25, your second baseman also needs to contribute offensively. These three stand above the rest with their elite blend of tools and reliability.
Ketel Marte (Arizona Diamondbacks, 96 OVR)
A switch-hitter with blazing speed, Marte remains one of the most consistent infielders in the game. He's been meta all year due to his elite contact stats, smooth fielding animations, and positional flexibility. Whether you need a leadoff hitter or a No. 3 spark plug, Marte delivers.
Mookie Betts (Los Angeles Dodgers, 95 OVR)
Betts continues to be the poster child for versatility. He can play multiple infield and outfield positions, hit for average, and steal bases with ease. His reaction time on defense is elite, making him a top-tier option for both sides of the ball. With Betts, you get five tools - and no weaknesses.
Chase Utley (Legend, 99 OVR)
One of the best pure second basemen in the game, Utley's 99 OVR legend card is simply unfair. His lefty bat annihilates right-handers, and his fielding ratings are among the best in MLB The Show 25. If you can afford this legend card, he's a must-start - the definition of S-tier.
???? Third Base (3B): Hot Corner Heroes
The third base position demands both reaction time and raw arm strength, and the following players redefine what it means to be elite at the hot corner.
Jose Ramirez (Cleveland Guardians, 95 OVR)
J-Ram is one of the most complete players in the game. As a switch-hitter with excellent power and speed, he creates constant matchup problems. His rocket arm and quick reflexes on defense save countless runs. Simply put, he's the gold standard at 3B.
Manny Machado (San Diego Padres, 86 OVR)
Machado might not have the flashiest rating, but recent updates boosted his power, making him a home run machine. His defensive prowess also remains underrated - his arm accuracy at the hot corner is elite, and his clutch factor in close games is top-tier.
Carlos Correa (Legend, 99 OVR)
Correa's 99 OVR legend card makes him an unstoppable defensive wall. Offensively, he's balanced - great contact, respectable power, and an ability to perform in clutch moments. He locks down third base while producing solid offensive numbers, giving you stability every inning.
Shortstop (SS): The Heart of the Infield
Shortstop is often the most dynamic position in baseball, and in MLB The Show 25, it's home to several of the game's true superstars.
Bobby Witt Jr. (Kansas City Royals, 96 OVR)
Witt Jr. combines elite athleticism with surprising pop. His 96 OVR card has risen through the ranks thanks to his mix of speed, arm strength, and power. Expect him to wreak havoc on the basepaths - and don't be surprised when he ropes doubles into the gap.
Francisco Lindor (New York Mets, 95 OVR)
A switch-hitter who thrives under pressure, Lindor brings elite defensive play and consistent offensive production. His animations are buttery smooth, and his Clutch and Fielding quirks make him invaluable for tight games.
Gunnar Henderson (Baltimore Orioles, 94 OVR)
The young star has arrived. Henderson's card offers one of the best power swings among infielders, and recent buffs have elevated him to S-tier territory. He's the perfect mix of youth, energy, and elite attributes - a must-own for modern rosters.
A-Tier Infielders: Solid, Reliable, and Cost-Effective
Not everyone can afford the top-tier legends, and that's where the A-tier comes in. These players may not have 99 ratings, but they can anchor your lineup and are often far more affordable - especially if you're grabbing MLB The Show 25 stubs from marketplaces like U4GM.
First Base (1B)
Oscar Charleston (Legend, 99 OVR): Vintage all-around threat with power and speed. Matchup quirks can be situational, but his production is elite.
Dick Allen (Legend, 99 OVR): Absolute slugger with strong defensive numbers. Availability in packs can limit how often you'll see him.
Salvador Perez (Legend, 99 OVR): Primarily a catcher, but with his 1B secondary, he offers great lineup flexibility and high contact stats.
Second Base (2B)
No current A-tier standouts beyond the top meta picks, but keep an eye on upcoming Season updates - new stat boosts often shift rankings dramatically.
Third Base (3B)
Rafael Devers (Boston Red Sox, 86 OVR): Reliable lefty bat that crushes right-handers. Great swing timing and solid clutch factor.
Matt Chapman (San Francisco Giants, 86 OVR): Defensive god. His bat is improving after September patches, making him a balanced option.
Eugenio Suarez (Arizona Diamondbacks, 86 OVR): A home run threat, though his swing timing can be inconsistent.
Shortstop (SS)
Elly De La Cruz (Cincinnati Reds, 93 OVR): Blazing speed and 99 steal rating make him electric. Slightly inconsistent contact keeps him from S-tier.
Corey Seager (Texas Rangers, 92 OVR): One of the smoothest swings in the game with elite power to all fields.
Trea Turner (Philadelphia Phillies, 90 OVR): Lightning-fast baserunner and clutch hitter - perfect for small-ball lineups.
Final Thoughts: Building Around the Infield Meta
The MLB The Show 25 meta continues to evolve, but one thing is certain - infielders who bring versatility, defense, and power remain the cornerstone of any elite Diamond Dynasty team. Bryce Harper, Ketel Marte, and Bobby Witt Jr. headline the current S-tier for their ability to impact every phase of the game.
If you're aiming for consistent wins, invest wisely in these game-changers. Whether it's Harper's power, Marte's switch-hitting finesse, or Witt Jr.'s speed, these players define the meta - and buy MLB Stubs cheap your road to victory.
Comments (0)