MMOEXP-MLB The Show 25: Top-Tier Infielders Explained

MLB The Show 25 Infielders Tier List Breakdown

 

As the MLB regular season winds down in late September 2025, MLB The Show 25 remains in peak form, reflecting not only the thrill of playoff races but also the evolving meta of Diamond Dynasty. This year's patches have brought subtle yet meaningful tweaks to contact ratings, swing timing windows, and defensive animations-shaking up how infielders perform across all modes. From hard-hitting corner basemen to slick double-play maestros, the infield has never felt more balanced or competitive.

 

Below is a full breakdown of the top infielders in MLB The Show 25, ranked by power, contact, fielding reliability, arm strength, and meta synergy. Whether you're grinding Ranked Seasons, tackling Conquest maps, MLB The Show 25 Stubs or simply chasing your dream team, knowing which infielders stand out will keep your lineup consistent in every clutch situation.

 

S-Tier: The Complete Infield Dominators

 

Corey Seager (SS/2B)

Seager's balanced profile continues to define the top tier. With elite contact against both sides, smooth defensive mechanics, and reliable reaction times, he's the blueprint of a shortstop in this year's game. The 99 OVR Seager card hits for both power and consistency, and his swing plane makes perfect contact far more forgiving. His only weakness is average speed, but his awareness in the field compensates for it.

 

José Ramírez (3B/2B)

No infield tier list would be complete without Ramírez. His switch-hitting ability, pop, and defensive flexibility make him invaluable. The meta this year favors quick, compact swings, and Ramírez delivers one of the smoothest animations in The Show 25. He's also surprisingly quick on the basepaths, making him a dangerous two-way threat.

 

Freddie Freeman (1B)

First base has a deep pool of mashers, but Freeman separates himself through superior contact and clutch hitting. The patch that slightly reduced exit velocity penalties on inside pitches gives Freeman new life against elite right-handers. His Gold Glove-level defense is a rare bonus at a power position where most players are liabilities with the glove.

 

A-Tier: Elite Performers with Minor Flaws

 

Mookie Betts (2B/SS)

Betts' unique fielding animations and top-tier reaction time make him one of the smoothest middle infielders in MLB The Show 25. His secondary at shortstop gives teams lineup flexibility, and he boasts incredible contact and plate discipline. However, his arm strength slightly trails true shortstops like Seager or Trea Turner, keeping him just below the top tier.

 

Rafael Devers (3B)

Devers brings thunder to the hot corner with raw power that few can match. The contact nerfs in the latest patch affect him a bit more than some of his peers, especially against lefties, but he remains one of the most feared sluggers when you square up pitches. Defensively, he's serviceable rather than exceptional, making him a great but not flawless pick.

 

Marcus Semien (2B)

Semien remains a staple thanks to balanced stats and top-tier durability. He performs in clutch moments and is especially useful in offline and Ranked play where consistency wins out. His swing is compact, and his fielding metrics make him dependable in turning tough double plays.

 

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (1B/3B)

Guerrero Jr. crushes anything middle-in, but his first-step quickness defensively can hurt you against fast grounders. He's best deployed in lineups that rely on heavy offense. If your goal is to intimidate pitchers and rack up early runs, he's your guy.

 

B-Tier: Reliable Starters and Budget Beasts

 

Trea Turner (SS/2B)

Turner's speed and baserunning still shine, but he's less dominant in The Show 25 than in previous years due to toned-down bunt and steal effectiveness. That said, his swing is incredibly smooth, and his versatility at short or second makes him one of the better all-around cards if you're building a balanced team.

 

Matt Olson (1B)

Olson offers classic left-handed power with solid discipline, making him an ideal first baseman for players who love pulling the ball. His fielding is average but predictable, which is valuable in high-pressure games. Against right-handers, he's still a nightmare.

 

Bobby Witt Jr. (SS/3B)

Witt's athleticism keeps him relevant despite some inconsistencies at the plate. His defensive range is among the best at shortstop, and his arm can gun down even the fastest runners. If his timing window fits your playstyle, he's capable of elite performances, but mastering his swing takes practice.

 

Jake Cronenworth (2B/1B)

A classic under-the-radar player, Cronenworth's versatility and disciplined approach make him ideal for budget squads. He doesn't lead any category, but he rarely hurts your team-especially in Ranked where you need reliability over flash.

 

C-Tier: Serviceable Role Players

 

Paul Goldschmidt (1B)

Goldschmidt's 2025 version feels slightly outdated compared to younger, faster options. He still provides solid right-handed power and can drive in runs in clutch spots, but his lack of agility and lower reaction times limit his defensive upside.

 

Nolan Arenado (3B)

Once an S-tier mainstay, Arenado's decreased contact ratings and slower swing animation have moved him down the list. He's still one of the most dependable fielders in the game-no one fields a barehander like Nolan-but his offense can feel streaky.

 

Gleyber Torres (2B/SS)

Torres is fine for players needing a mid-tier infielder with decent pop and good fielding. He doesn't excel anywhere, but his swing is consistent and easy to time. Great for filler roles or secondary squads.

 

The Current Meta and Final Thoughts

 

The MLB The Show 25 meta for infielders now rewards consistency over raw attributes. Timing, swing animation, and reaction speed matter more than ever. The September patch normalized contact windows, meaning even top-tier hitters must rely on player skill rather than inflated stats. As a result, balanced players like Corey Seager and José Ramírez dominate the current landscape, while pure power bats like Devers and Guerrero Jr. shine only in the right hands.

 

Fielding, too, plays a bigger role in tight Ranked games. Quick animations and accurate throws often decide outcomes in extra innings. Investing in elite defensive infielders will save runs-and games-over the course of a long season.

 

If you're building your dream team and want to accelerate progress, you can find fast and secure stub options through trusted marketplaces like MMOEXP. It's an efficient way to strengthen your roster without weeks of repetitive grinding.