MMOEXP-MLB The Show 25: Ranking Every Pitcher From S to F Tier

 

As October rolls in, MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty captures the postseason intensity like no other mode.In-game, the right pitchers can transform your squad from an average team to a playoff powerhouse.The difference between a shutout sweep and a season-ending loss often comes down to the rotation and bullpen you assemble.With live series adjustments, stamina quirks, and PlayStyles+ affecting pitch effectiveness, knowing which arms dominate the meta is crucial for any serious player.This tier list examines the top-performing pitchers in early October 2025, providing actionable insight for  MLB 25 Stubs constructing a staff capable of carrying you deep into Diamond Dynasty's ranked seasons or Conquest maps.

 

God Tier Pitchers: Untouchable Rotation Anchors

 

At the top of the pitching hierarchy are the God Tier arms-pitchers who redefine control, strikeout potential, and clutch performance.These hurlers consistently dominate both offline and online formats, capable of shutting down any hitter regardless of lineup strength.

 

Key traits for God Tier pitchers include: elite velocity, multiple effective pitches, and PlayStyles+ that amplify key scenarios, such as Filthy Pitch for punishing 0-2 counts or Ice Cold for maintaining composure late in tight games.Their stamina allows them to go deep into games without risking efficiency drops, making them perfect anchors for your rotation.

 

Examples include:

 

Max Scherzer – Combining elite four-seam velocity with devastating secondary pitches, Scherzer can blow by hitters while maintaining pinpoint control.His Filthy Pitch PlayStyle+ ensures breaking balls hit the corners with surgical precision.

 

Gerrit Cole – An overpowering fastball and slider combo, Cole excels in high-leverage situations.Perfect for dominating mid-to-late innings in ranked seasons.

 

Jacob deGrom – Even at reduced stamina, deGrom's pitch movement and location mastery allow him to control games, limiting walks and forcing weak contact.

 

God Tier pitchers are indispensable in constructing a rotation capable of competing against stacked opponents in Conquest and Weekend League-style runs.

 

Elite Tier Pitchers: High-Impact Workhorses

 

Elite Tier pitchers sit just below the God Tier in terms of raw dominance but still offer exceptional value for rotations and bullpens.They often excel in one or two critical areas-velocity, movement, or clutch performance-making them ideal for specific roles.

 

Examples include:

 

Clayton Kershaw – A finesse pitcher with a sublime curveball and changeup combination, Kershaw can neutralize powerful lineups when managed correctly.

 

Walker Buehler – Elite strikeout potential with solid stamina, perfect for handling the top of an opponent's order multiple times.

 

Shane Bieber – Strong command and devastating slider placement make Bieber a high-floor, high-ceiling rotation piece.

 

Elite Tier arms are great for balancing rotations, particularly when paired with God Tier starters to maintain consistent performance across all innings.They are also more budget-friendly in terms of stubs, making them accessible for players looking to optimize their roster without maxing out resources.

 

High Tier Pitchers: Reliable Rotation Contributors

 

High Tier pitchers provide consistency and can excel in either starting or relief roles.While they may not have the breakout potential of God or Elite Tier arms, their stats often make them reliable performers against mid-tier opponents.

 

Examples include:

 

Zack Wheeler – Balanced mix of power and control allows him to pitch deep into games without risk of wild innings.

 

Lucas Giolito – Heavy breaking ball movement makes him a threat against contact-heavy lineups.

 

Chris Sale – Known for high strikeout upside and situational dominance, Sale can change momentum quickly when deployed strategically.

 

High Tier pitchers are excellent for teams looking to fill gaps in their rotation or bullpen without spending excessively.They can reliably manage innings and maintain low ERAs against mid-tier competition, ensuring your team remains competitive throughout the season.

 

Mid Tier Pitchers: Specialized Roles and Matchup Play

 

Mid Tier pitchers serve niche roles in the rotation or bullpen, often excelling against specific hitter types or in particular situations.They are ideal for matchups where you can exploit weaknesses, such as facing contact hitters with high-spin breaking balls or left-handed sluggers with specialized deliveries.

 

Examples include:

 

Joe Musgrove – Effective situational pitcher, especially against power hitters due to slider and cutter combination.

 

Kenta Maeda – Reliable in relief or spot starts, his pitch mix allows for controlled outings without high risk.

 

Eduardo Rodriguez – A solid groundball pitcher, ideal for controlling lineups in ballpark-friendly to hitters.

 

Mid Tier arms are less likely to carry games on their own but can be critical for maintaining depth and ensuring that your rotation or bullpen has options for varied matchups.

 

Low Tier Pitchers: Budget Options and Depth

 

Low Tier pitchers are primarily used for depth or as budget-friendly options to complete missions, live series objectives, or grind shorter stints in ranked play.While they may lack elite velocity or movement, they can be serviceable in controlled environments.

 

Examples include:

 

Mike Foltynewicz – Decent strikeout potential but inconsistent command limits long-term use.

 

Brandon Woodruff – Effective against lower-tier lineups but struggles against high-contact opponents.

 

Jon Gray – Fastball-heavy pitcher with limited secondary options; best used in mop-up innings or niche situations.

 

Optimizing Your Rotation

 

Constructing a competitive rotation in MLB The Show 25 requires balancing talent, stamina, and PlayStyles+.God and Elite Tier pitchers should anchor your rotation, while High and Mid Tier arms provide depth and matchup flexibility.Consider bullpen composition as well: power arms with high velocity for closing games, and finesse pitchers capable of controlling innings in longer outings.

 

Additionally, Pay attention to community trends and live series updates, as these can affect pitch effectiveness and stamina quirks.Efficient rotation management ensures you're not overextending pitchers and maximizes their impact across multiple games.

 

Conclusion

 

October in MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty is all about building a pitching staff capable of dominating in high-stakes scenarios.Understanding the tier hierarchy-from God Tier aces to Low Tier depth arms-helps you make informed decisions about rotations, bullpen roles, and matchups.By focusing on high-OVR starters, smart PlayStyles+, and strategic bullpen deployment, players can turn their pitching staff into a playoff-contending machine.